Is life predetermined? For all practical purposes the answer is NO

If you’re in a rush here’s the quick answer: If life was pre-determined we’d be able to forecast the weather perfectly, too.

Recently I’ve spent quite some time on the topic of artificial intelligence and the fascinating question of what is consciousness. What would it entail to build a man-made self-conscious system? Along came the question of predeterminism of a system and predeterminism of life. Small things.

I’m a CPU architect by profession and have spent many waking hours of my life creating deterministic simulation environments to verify our complex micro-processors. This sounds easy but is actually really hard. It also means that you need to limit yourself to certain design styles that yield deterministic and therefore perfectly reproducible results. A good example of things that can destroy determinism are asynchronous events in a real system, such as interrupts (i.e. keyboard key strokes) that can invoke interrupt routines and disrupt the expected instruction stream. This particular instance is a solvable problem, but in general asynchronous events in non-linear systems are the culprit.

In complex systems with non-linear chaotic behavior, such as weather systems, we can make statistical assertions about their general behavior. But when it comes to determining exactly how the system is going to behave close to a points of instability not even infinite precision in the description of the current condition can predict the exact outcome. We can only make statistical statements about the outcome. This property of chaotic systems prevents us from predicting all asynchronous events that might affect our lives in one way or another. These complex and at times unpredictable behaviors apply as much to weather systems as they apply to outbreaks of diseases that might affect certain individuals. Think of a viral infection causing fever and seizures in humans, heavily affecting their thinking process. Physical diseases might even permanently alter brain structures and synaptic connections. All of which would have the potential to change an individuals behaviour/mood/decision making process in the future. Please note that I’m talking about conscious decision making of the individual. Taken to the extreme sicknesses can cause personality changes that will alter a persons decision outcome. I.e. as a result of such a personality change someone decides to persue a different professional career, with far reaching consequences for his life in the long term (economic outlook, location of job, consumed literature, etc.)

So while for long periods of times individuals live in the linearly predictable parts of the world and causing behaviors that appear to be largely predictable (i.e. I get on the train every morning to get to work and then attend a recurring meeting), these asynchronous events can wreak havoc on long term outcomes of decisions affecting an individuals life.

Therefore predeterminism isn’t a property of human life or even biological life as a whole. But it’s largely predictable enough to exploit long times of relative stability in ways to learn and predict and benefit from these behaviors – for yourself and 3rd parties.

So where does that leave machines? That’s a topic for another post…

 

Disney World 2016

Dear Walt,

Our family of three tried your “world” the first time this year. Our eight year old son loves his Pluto and he was ready to see the “world”. We did. Below is my summary of our three day stay over 2016 Thanksgiving when we visited “Magic Kingdom” and “Epcot”.

What works:
– Wrist band. Pretty slick. But needs even more integration with on site vendors (Arcade in Star Movies can’t be purchased with parents wrist band).
– Airport transfer – smooth.
– Efficiency – It’s apparent you care about efficiency and have spent quite a bit of engineering resources on it. It’s apparent and well done. It mostly works. But can be tweaked here and there.
– Safety. Seems to be paramount. Everywhere. Sure I get it. But it’s not really what I come for when I go on a vacation. I’m just not that worried about bruises, pinched fingers and broken legs. But different people have different priorities – I respect yours. But I’m fine vacationing in less safe and less predictable places – it’s what makes life fun. Your designers have forgotten that with there single track mind.
– There are rules for everything. And the friendly staff will let you know about them with a smile. Still annoying though. But the Germans would be proud of you and could still learn a thing or two from you about smiling 😉 .
– The pool worked – nice, big, clean – and safe – here it really matters and I was impressed with all the life guards.
– The magic Kingdom parade is magnificent.

Improvements:
– Better integration of electronics at attractions.
– Do staff better for peak times. When buses arrive, you’re understaffed in the hotels, and after that your employees look bored. Why not let some group of staff travel with the bus and take care of the group? There’s plenty of time on the transfer bus from and to the airport…
– Make the waiting lines part of the experience – because face it: they already are. The lines and flow is well organized, but waiting for 45min is boring, no matter how you cut it – even for adults. Make it part of the show instead. i.e. Entertainers that work the line, music, movies. Also a lost opportunity to sell more stuff to the crowd.
– Monetize on second chance rides – i.e. double the price every time you re-run a ride immediately (cash) – a kid can’t contain his/her immediate desire.
– Despite my son falling asleep with his stuffed Pluto since the age of 1 he was unable to talk to Pluto in the Magic Kingdom. He couldn’t stand the wait. Later on Pluto was gone.
– There’s no real choice anywhere – ‘the line starts here’ (there’s no second line), take the stairs, sorry can’t take the handicapped ramp. Everything is a single pass. If you don’t think so, visit your park in peak times. There’s no choice anywhere. Everything is a line. Cattle. Sheep. Maehhh!
– Introduce more hidden fast passes, VIP lines – there’s a reason airlines have elite, premium, 1st class and all kinds of different statuses – it’s good for business.
– Your resort food at Star Music sucks! It’s a crime. The only non-processed food option was a banana – come on you can do better than fat and salt. Super disappointed.
– The display of Indian settlement next to the train is atrocious. First we kill them, then we make them stuffed animals? Do their ears also wiggle like the deer’s? Cute – not.
– Alcoholic drinks: for a $10+ drink I expect more than a plastic cup. When I asked the bar tender to get at least the plastic cocktail glass shown in the picture she denied. Really? I have standards. You should have, too.
– Lack of traditional Disney character merchandise. I was ready to buy everything “Pluto” and everything “Goofy”. But there was barely any merchandise for those characters available – I only managed to spend $48 dollars. Lost business. Why not put a merchandise stand per character in each and every disney store? The money is with the parents.
– You succeeded to convince my wife that you were a family place – congratulations. But I don’t buy it. You’re a profit maximizing business first and far most.  Given your prices and the poor food everywhere  (you really don’t care about the long term health and wealth of your visitors, never mind your short term focus on safety). Preying on the low to middle income families and exploiting their consumerism is just not very high on my moral scale.

Epcot: I just don’t get that park. But then again I have a passport to travel the world and a wife from half around the world. Maybe the point of that park is drinking in public? If you meant to make food diversity the attraction you failed miserably. Overpriced mediocracy everywhere. Disappointing. Just shut it down or make the entire park the race track ?
The Race track was fun. But lack of electronics integration in the gift shop is disappointing. Put up a passport photo both that prints your designed car, not some lame intern developed pre produced icon next to your own visage for an insane price.

To sum it up: I’m glad to have visited Disney world once and I can confidently say I won’t be back. It was an OK experience, I never got into the fully immersed state of mind. I always felt I was part of someone else’s playbook, on my dime. The cost for the experience was about 1.5x too high for what I would have been willing to pay for it. We have more fun with less money on our other vacations with less waiting in lines. As a pre-packaged all happy deal I was 66% there. But I was too annoyed in-between. My son called the day of the Magic Kingdom visit “the worst day of my life” since he couldn’t redo the “Splash Mountain” run after chickening out the first time (the parents’ fast passes were used by that time) and he couldn’t talk to Pluto.

It’s my hope that you’ll take my feed-back as constructive criticism and that it will help you to improve your visitors’ experience over time.

Regards,
MrM.